An argument in favor of abortion in mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status of abortion

May 1, One of the most hotly contested issues inside and outside of biomedical ethics today is abortion.

An argument in favor of abortion in mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status of abortion

A Critique of Mary Anne Warren's On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Part III In part one of this series, I examined Warren's definition of humanity, and in part two I examined her argument about what a person is and showed why the unborn certainly qualify. Personhood Argument in Favor of Abortion Presentation by: Claire King. Abortion in History • Before antibiotics, abortions were an incredibly dangerous procedure for women • Legal until the late nineteenth century • states became able to legalize abortion, Mary Anne Warren’s Personhood Argument in Favor of Abortion. Mary Anne Warren: On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion fetus is similar to a "guppy" for a person to be a member of a moral community there must be 5 traits: consciousness, reasoning, self motivating, communicative and possessed of self concept.

This article will be the third part of five, in which I'll examine Warren's claims about the right to life. Fetal Development and the Right to Life Warren begins by merely asserting that the paradigm case for personhood is a normal human adult.

This strikes me as odd, though, considering that earlier she argued that we have no right to assume that genetic humanity is necessary for personhood.

Coming from central Europe, the whole abortion being a political issue is a strange one to me, help me understand. Criticism of Mary Anne Warren’s work (rational conclusions on the question of personhood) must, seeing the clear, rational, pragmatic and scientific argumentation in her work, be irrational and religiously biased. Mary Anne Warren: On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion fetus is similar to a "guppy" for a person to be a member of a moral community there must be 5 traits: consciousness, reasoning, self motivating, communicative and possessed of self concept. Port Manteaux churns out silly new words when you feed it an idea or two. Enter a word (or two) above and you'll get back a bunch of portmanteaux created by jamming together words that are conceptually related to your inputs.. For example, enter "giraffe" and you'll get .

On what grounds is a normal human adult our paradigm case for personhood? Warren simply doesn't bother to lay out an argument on this issue. In fact, her earlier argument seems to suggest that it would be improper to consider a human as our paradigm case at all. Nevertheless, with the adult human as a paradigm case, she uses this section to address two questions: Warren attempts to answer these questions by considering that human value develops gradually.

As one becomes more and more like a person, one becomes more and more valuable. Or she at least says that we should take that claim seriously that since the human individual develops sociologically in a continuous fashion, the rights of a human person might develop in the same way.

I really don't think we should. As pro-life philosopher Trent Horn has argued, personhood does not come in degrees so it can not be tied to a property that comes in degrees. You're either a person or you're not, so being a person is not tied into becoming more and more conscious, or self-aware, or looking more human, etc.

Download-Theses

Warren does correctly state that being genetically human, having recognizable human features, detectable brain activity, and viability are not among the relevant attributes for personhood. But they may as well be.

Claiming that these properties are morally relevant would be about as ad hoc as Warren's own list of attributes. Now Warren just keeps digging her hole even deeper. She argues that a seven- or eight-month-old fetus has some rudimentary consciousness and can even feel pain.

But does it satisfy condition one of her basic criteria for personhood?

Philosophical aspects of the abortion debate - Wikipedia

She writes, "Thus it is clear that even though a seven- or eight-month fetus has features which make it apt to arouse in us the same powerful protective instinct as is commonly aroused by a small infant, nevertheless it is not significantly more personlike than is a very small embryo.

It is somewhat more personlike; it can apparently feel and respond to pain, and it may even have a rudimentary form of consciousness, insofar as its brain is quite active.

Nevertheless, it seems safe to say that it is not fully conscious, in the way that an infant of a few months is, and that it cannot reason, or communicate messages of indefinitely many sorts, does not engage in self-motivated activity, and has no self-awareness. Thus, in the relevant aspects, a fetus, even a fully developed one, is considerably less personlike than is the average mature mammal, indeed the average fish.Coming from central Europe, the whole abortion being a political issue is a strange one to me, help me understand.

Criticism of Mary Anne Warren’s work (rational conclusions on the question of personhood) must, seeing the clear, rational, pragmatic and scientific argumentation in her work, be irrational and religiously biased.

A Critique of Mary Anne Warren's On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Part III In part one of this series, I examined Warren's definition of humanity, and in part two I examined her argument about what a person is and showed why the unborn certainly qualify.

Port Manteaux churns out silly new words when you feed it an idea or two.

An argument in favor of abortion in mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status of abortion

Enter a word (or two) above and you'll get back a bunch of portmanteaux created by jamming together words that are conceptually related to your inputs.. For example, enter "giraffe" and you'll get .

Download-Theses Mercredi 10 juin Start studying Philosophy Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

Mary Anne Warren – On the Legal and Moral Status of Abortion | Introduction to Philosophy References and Further Reading 1.

Moral and Legal status of Abortion: Mary Anne Warren The traditional anti-abortion argument fails to distinguish between the moral sense of "human being," which implies full membership in the moral community, and the genetic. Mary Anne Warren: On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion fetus is similar to a "guppy" for a person to be a member of a moral community there must be 5 traits: consciousness, reasoning, self motivating, communicative and possessed of self concept.

Abortion | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy